Tool 1 · Survey

Will a thermal scan work on this roof?

Three questions about the roof, its surface and what is under the membrane say whether our drone moisture scan will work here, and if not, which survey does. It suits single-ply, mod bit and smooth built-up roofs over insulation board; gravel-surfaced built-up is a poor fit. It does not suit ballast or pavers, metal panels, spray foam, bare concrete, or a reflective or white-coated surface.

Two adjoining flat commercial roofs from above: one smooth dark gray membrane with a drain and rooftop units, the other covered in loose round stone, split by a brick parapet

Three questions

Answer for the roof as it is today

One roof level at a time: a building with several levels can get a different answer for each. Not sure is a real answer here, and the result says what would settle it.

  1. 1 What kind of roof is it?

    Answer for the top layer you would walk on. Loose stone or pavers on top count as ballast; gravel set into a built-up roof is gravel-surfaced.

  2. 2 What does the surface look like from above?

    As it looks in daylight. For a gravel-surfaced, ballasted, metal, spray foam or bare concrete roof, this answer does not change the result.

  3. 3 What is between the deck and the membrane?

    An old roof plan, the original drawings or a past core report usually says. For a gravel-surfaced, ballasted, metal, spray foam or bare concrete roof, this answer does not change the result.

Answer the three questions and the result for this roof appears here.

A thermal scan does not suit a ballasted roof

Stone ballast and pavers store the day's heat themselves and mask the small differences a scan reads, so a thermal scan does not suit this roof, and it is surveyed another way: a nuclear or capacitance survey takes readings on a grid across the roof. Which one suits depends on the membrane under the stone; capacitance, for one, is not used over black EPDM, which leaves the nuclear gauge and cores. Whatever either survey finds, cores confirm it.

Moisture survey methods compared

Gravel-surfaced built-up is a poor fit for a thermal scan

Gravel set into a built-up roof throws warm patterns that can be impossible to tell from small wet areas, so a thermal scan is a poor fit here, and the roof is usually surveyed another way: a capacitance or nuclear survey takes readings on a grid across the roof. Whatever either survey finds, cores confirm it.

Moisture survey methods compared

On metal panels, the survey is a walk, not a flight

Reflections off the panels spoil a thermal reading, so a thermal scan is the wrong tool on a metal panel roof, and a capacitance scanner does not suit metal either. The survey for a metal restoration is a walk of every seam, lap, fastener row, curb and penetration, with the roof plan in hand, noting the panel type and where the rust is. A membrane section on the same building may still suit a scan; run the tool again for it. If anyone suspects wet insulation under the panels, only an opening or a core confirms it.

Restoring a metal roof

On spray foam, cores and a walk-through do the work

Closed-cell spray foam does not hold water the way board insulation does, so a thermal camera has little to find in it. A foam roof is surveyed on foot with the roof plan, marking worn and missing coating, sun-damaged foam, gouges, pecked holes, blisters and every penetration. An electrical-impedance (capacitance) survey is another method used on foam. Whatever any survey suggests, cores show whether water has got into the foam.

Restoring a spray foam roof

A bare or coated concrete deck gives a thermal scan nothing to read

A thermal scan looks for wet insulation under a membrane, and exposed concrete has none on top. The deck is surveyed on foot: cracks across the slab, joints whose sealant has let go, spalls, failed sealant at penetrations and water standing in low areas, with an adhesion test patch to settle whether a coating holds. A deep spall or a crack that keeps moving goes to the building's engineer. Where the concrete sits under insulation and a membrane, answer for that roof instead; there, as on every roof, cores confirm what any survey finds.

Restoring a concrete roof deck

Over lightweight concrete or poured gypsum, a scan is not recommended

The camera looks for wet insulation, but lightweight insulating concrete and poured gypsum hold moisture of their own, from when they were poured and from service, which makes a thermal survey over them difficult to read. Cores say what the deck and the layers above it hold, and a walk-through finds the laps, flashings and penetrations worth checking first. Whether a capacitance or nuclear survey adds anything on that deck is for the contractor or a roof consultant to say. Whatever any survey finds, cores confirm it.

Moisture survey methods compared

EPS foam board gives a thermal camera little to find

A thermal scan finds wet insulation because wet insulation holds the day's heat. Expanded polystyrene does not hold water the way perlite, wood fiber or glass fiber board does, so the camera is the wrong tool for it. Cores say what is actually up there and whether it is wet, and a walk-through finds the laps, flashings and penetrations worth checking first. Ask whoever surveys the roof whether a capacitance or nuclear survey suits that build-up. Whatever any survey finds, cores confirm it.

How core samples confirm a survey

With no insulation above the deck, a thermal scan has nothing to find

ASTM C1153, the standard practice for infrared roof moisture surveys, is written for roofs with insulation above the deck, against the membrane. With the membrane laid straight on the deck, there is no wet insulation for the camera to look for. A walk of the roof and cores where anything is suspect settle it; over a wood, concrete or gypsum deck an electrical-impedance (capacitance) survey is another option, though not over black EPDM. Whatever any survey finds, cores confirm it.

Moisture survey methods compared

A white or aluminum surface: ask before anyone flies

Thermal readings are less dependable on reflective surfaces. A white surface reflects sunlight, so less of the day's heat goes into the roof for the camera to read after sunset; an aluminum coating adds reflections that spoil a thermal image. On a highly reflective or already white-coated roof a scan is the wrong tool. Tell us what is on the roof and how long it has been there, and we will say whether a flight is worth it or which survey fits instead. Either way, cores confirm what any survey finds.

Moisture survey methods compared

A good fit: request a moisture scan

A single-ply, modified bitumen or smooth built-up membrane over insulation boards, with a dark surface that takes in the sun, is the roof the method was made for. It needs a sunny day followed by a clear, dry, calm evening; the drone flies once the sun has set. You get a map with any areas that look wet outlined and measured in square feet, video from the flight and a written assessment. Nothing has to be decided until you have seen the map. We arrange scans anywhere in the US and fly only with the owner's go-ahead. The scan marks suspects; the cores confirm them.

Request a moisture scan

Likely a good fit, once you know what is under the membrane

The roof type and the surface suit a thermal scan. The camera looks for wet insulation boards, so the one thing left to know is what lies between the deck and the membrane: EPS foam board, lightweight concrete or poured gypsum would change the answer. Request the scan with what you know, including anything an old roof plan or a past core report says, and we will say whether to fly before anyone does. The scan marks suspects; the cores confirm them.

Request a moisture scan

Not sure yet: send us the roof

Not knowing what is on the roof, or under it, is normal. Send the building's address with whatever you know: what the roof looks like, its age, what an old roof plan or the last roofer's paperwork says. We will say whether a thermal scan suits the roof, or which survey does, before anything is booked. We arrange drone moisture scans for commercial low-slope roofs anywhere in the US, and fly only with the owner's go-ahead. Whatever any survey finds, cores confirm it.

Request a moisture scan

Why these three answers decide it

A thermal scan reads heat, not water. Through a sunny day the roof takes in the sun; after sunset, wet insulation under the membrane holds that heat longer than dry insulation, so it shows up warmer on the camera. Each question asks whether that can happen on this roof, and whether a camera can see it when it does. Infrared roof moisture surveys covers the method in full.

The roof type. The method is built for insulation laid above the deck, under the membrane; ASTM C1153, the standard practice for infrared roof moisture surveys, is written for that kind of roof.

  • Single-ply, modified bitumen, smooth built-up: the roof the method was made for.
  • Gravel-surfaced built-up: a poor fit; gravel throws warm patterns that can be impossible to tell from small wet areas.
  • Ballast or pavers: not suited; they store the day’s heat and mask the differences the camera reads.
  • Metal panels: not suited; reflections spoil the reading.
  • Bare concrete: nothing to read; there is no insulation on top.
  • Spray foam: little to find; closed-cell foam does not hold water the way board insulation does.

The surface. The method runs on the day’s sun. White finish coats reflect sunlight and keep the roof surface cooler, so less heat goes into the roof for the camera to read after sunset. An aluminum coating is made to reflect, and reflections spoil a thermal image. A white coating makes later thermal work harder, which is one more reason to scan before you coat rather than after.

What is under the membrane. The camera is looking for insulation that has taken up water. EPS foam board does not hold water the way perlite, wood fiber or glass fiber board does. Lightweight insulating concrete and poured gypsum hold moisture from when they were poured and from service, which makes a thermal survey difficult. With no insulation above the deck, there is none to find. Wet roof insulation explains why wet board comes out before any coating goes on.

What no answer changes

  • A scan needs a sunny day followed by a clear, dry, calm evening.
  • It shows temperature differences, not water: rooftop exhaust, ponded water and debris can read warm too.
  • A camera overhead cannot see under rooftop units.
  • The scan marks suspects; the cores confirm them. Capacitance and nuclear readings need cores too.

Coating makers, Sherwin-Williams included, require wet insulation to be found and replaced before a coating goes on. Whichever survey suits the roof, that is the job it does. Uniflex also requires a moisture survey, by a qualified person, on every Uniflex system-warranty project, and a third-party survey for a 15-year warranty request; whether a survey is accepted is Uniflex’s call, not ours.

Moisture survey methods compared sets infrared, capacitance, nuclear and cores side by side, and core samples explains how a finding gets confirmed. To see what a scan delivers, see a sample scan: a sample from a real scan, with the address, the people and the companies removed and the map re-oriented. The sample shows the map and the image pairs; a full scan also comes with video from the flight and a written assessment.

What the tool is, and is not

It sorts what you know about the roof. It is not a survey: the cores say what is wet, the contractor writes the scope, and the building’s engineer decides anything structural.

Send the address, and we will say what fits

Put the building's address in the message, with the roof type and anything you know about what is under it. We will tell you whether a thermal scan suits it or which survey does, and quote the scan for your roof if it fits. We arrange scans for commercial low-slope roofs anywhere in the US.